The 12-Letter Word Giving The Government Sleepless Nights

by Derek O'Brien

The BJP floundered in the 2024 Lok Sabha election. The floundering continued on the floor of both Houses where Members of Parliament from the INDIA parties delivered multiple speeches that were well-structured, well-executed, and rich in content. A recurring theme in many of these powerful interventions on the Budget was a 12-letter word giving Modi and his coalition sleepless Delhi nights: unemployment.

Article 41 of the Constitution states, “The State shall, within the limits of its economic capacity and development, make effective provision for securing the right to work, to education, and to public assistance in cases of unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement, and in other cases of undeserved want.”

Employment And Food Insecurity

Many MPs in the Opposition quoted CMIE data about the employment rate – which is the ‘proportion of employed persons in the working age population’ – recorded at 37% in June 2024. The Global Hunger Index 2023 was often referred to last week in Parliament – India ranked 111th out of 125 countries. Despite improvements in food production and distribution, food insecurity persists, particularly in marginalised communities.

Impact On Personal Freedoms

A citizen cannot truly enjoy any liberty when perpetually anxious about her family’s unmet needs. This becomes even more important when the Budget skirts around the issues of health, nutrition, social security, and education. It is difficult to think about personal liberties on an empty stomach.

MGNREGA

MGNREGA addresses the issue of Right to Work. However, it ensures it as a statutory right, instead of being a Fundamental Right. The latter cannot be taken away by an amendment of the MGNREGA Act. It bears repetition that states have been constantly deprived of MGNREGA funds. The Union owes the West Bengal government alone ₹ 7,000 Crores for the scheme.

In a labour-surplus society, why then is the Union government often selling the family silver to private entities? Two dozen large Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs) have been privatised. This is not the solution. Should it not be the duty of the state to offer the labour force multiple opportunities for employment? There are 30 lakh vacancies in the Union government and government-controlled organisations. What is the road map and timelines for these vacancies to be filled? Parliament is in session. The government must provide answers.

Education And Skill Development

The Union has an obligation to provide quality education and skill development to improve employability, and guarantee livelihood. But Budget 2024 has allocated only ₹ 1.20 lakh crore to education, which is a 2% decline from Actuals (Rs 1.23 lakh crores) in 2023-24.

Right To Livelihood As A Fundamental Right

Through judicial interpretation, the Right to Livelihood has been read into the Right to Life, even though it is not explicitly listed among the Fundamental Rights in Part III of the Constitution. The Supreme Court emphasised, “An equally important facet of the right to life is the right to livelihood because no person can live without the means of living, that is, the means of livelihood. If the right to livelihood is not treated as a part of the constitutional right to life, the easiest way of depriving a person of his right to life would be to deprive him of his means of livelihood to the point of abrogation. Such deprivation would not only strip life of its effective content and meaningfulness but also make life impossible to live.”

The Right to Work, outlined in the directive principles, has been interpreted alongside the Rights to Livelihood and Life, evolving into a Fundamental Right through judicial pronouncements. Integrating the Right to Work into Fundamental Rights, and ensuring that policies are designed to create sustainable job opportunities, is paramount to ensuring employment. Even after a tepid performance in the elections, where they were punished by young people, this government refuses to prioritise investment in education and vocational training.

Only talk about cooperative federalism will not do. States politically opposed to the ruling dispensation are deprived on flimsy grounds for years of their MGNREGA funds. These are funds due to people who have completed their work, and have still not been paid.

Additionally, fostering a more inclusive job market by supporting small businesses and encouraging entrepreneurship can play a critical role in generating employment. By taking these steps, India can better align its economic policies with its constitutional commitments and provide more meaningful support to its citizens.

The Right to Work still requires the state to take responsibility, and appropriate legislative actions, to fully provide citizens with the Right to Life, Livelihood, and Dignity.

[This article was also published in NDTV | Monday, July 29, 2024]

Why voters no longer believe “Modi ki guarantee”

by Derek O'Brien

January 12, 2024. “Modi’s guarantee begins where expectations from others ends”. The launch of “Modi ki Guarantee” as Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s key campaign slogan for the general elections 2024.

March 30, 2024. This column appears, with the headline, “No warranty for ‘Modi Ki Guarantee’”.

April 14, 2024. The BJP launches its manifesto. The cover page says “Modi ki Guarantee 2024”.

April 27, 2024. The day after the second phase of elections conclude, the

“Modi ki Guarantee” slogan is put away into the closet.

In the world of marketing, a brand proposition, as the term connotes, is a promissory note, that is, a promise of substance being made to the customer that will be fulfilled by the brand. It reiterates to consumers the key reasons to assess, reassess, buy or repurchase the brand.

Brand propositions should be conceived of with great thought and care, because you should not promise more than you can deliver. As the marketing adage goes, you can get someone to buy something once, or even twice, but eventually the consumer will see through you. Brand propositions should ideally last for years — even decades.

And finally, the success of the brand lies not in the proposition itself, but in its successful delivery, in all channels of customer engagement. This means that everyone, from the worker on the factory floor, to the quality control system, to the salesman, the outlet and the after-sales-service has to be focussed and committed to that goal. This is what delivers customer satisfaction and the ultimate prize, brand loyalty.

It is, therefore, not surprising but amusing — and a sobering lesson — that the BJP’s brand proposition “Modi Ki Guarantee” for the Lok Sabha elections 2024, barely lasted a couple of months.

Here are 10 statements quoted verbatim from the BJP manifesto. The paragraphs accompanying each statement provide clues as to why the key proposition, propagated in January 2024, has virtually disappeared in the campaign by early May.

We will ensure the dignity of women: Hathras. Unnao. Kathua. Bilkis Bano. Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh. Prajwal Revanna. Sandeskhali.

We have gone from a nation that was in the “Fragile Five” to a nation that is one of the top 5 economies of the world: Ten years ago, India was the tenth biggest economy in the world with household financial savings at 7.2 per cent of the GDP. Today, as the fifth largest economy, income inequality is even worse than it was during the British Raj. Net financial household savings are at a 50-year low, at 5.1 per cent of the GDP in 2022-23.

Fifty-plus crore citizens have joined the banking system through PM Jan Dhan Account: As of December 2023, one out of five Jan Dhan accounts created has been inoperative/dormant for over two years. This translates to 10.34 crore accounts not being used at all. An amount of Rs 12,779 crore is lying unused in these dormant accounts.

Four-plus crore families now have pucca houses under the PM Awas Yojana and other initiatives: As of January 2024, one out of three houses that were sanctioned under PMAY-U are yet to be completed.

Improved health care of women by making sanitary pads available at Rs 1: In 2019-21, one out of five women did not use hygienic methods of protection during menstruation. One out of four girls either misses school during periods or discontinues her education entirely due to inadequate facilities and other obstacles.

1.4-plus crore young citizens availed skill training under the PM Kaushal Vikas Yojana: As per the 2022-23 Standing Committee on Labour, Textiles and Skill Development, the placement rate for the PMKVY 2 stood at 23 per cent. For PMKVY 3, it was even lower, at just 8 per cent. As of June 30, 2022, over half of the budget allocated was unutilised.

Unprecedented hike in MSP: Farmers protested to demand MSP as a guarantee. They were not allowed to enter Delhi, teargassed and sprayed with water cannons. In 2024, 19 farmers died and 40 got injured during the “Dilli Chalo” protest.

Unprecedented improvements in connectivity of the Northeast by expansion of roads, bridges, railways and airports: Out of 181 projects sanctioned under North East Special Infrastructure Development Scheme, only 25 have been completed as of December 2023. In the last six years, the scheme utilised only 40 per cent of the allocated funds.

Constructed 3.7 lakh km of rural roads in villages under PM Gram Sadak Yojana: The scheme has four verticals of which none had completed all the sanctioned projects as of January 2023. Two of these verticals had a deadline of 2022. Road Connectivity Project on Left Wing Extremism Areas, which had a deadline of March 2023, has only completed half of the sanctioned kms.

Achieved 100 per cent electrification by providing electricity connection to 2.8-plus crore families under Saubhagya: According to the government’s definition, a village is considered electrified if just 10 per cent of households in a village have electricity. In 2021, as per some states, nearly 12 lakh households were yet to be electrified. Moreover, according to a response by the Minister of Power in Rajya Sabha in December 2023, nearly five lakh households were left to be electrified in Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Andhra Pradesh.

“Modi ki Guarantee” is a brand proposition that the consumer did not believe. No wonder it was quickly put to bed. A new brand proposition is now being brazenly propagated. But that’s the subject of a column after the results.

[This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, May 10, 2024]

No warranty for ‘Modi Ki Guarantee’

by Derek O'Brien

On March 31, the INDIA alliance parties will hold a mega rally at Ramlila Maidan in New Delhi. The message for India’s 2024 general elections is a simple one: BJP versus Democracy. On the other flank, BJP offers “Modi Ki Guarantee”.

Here are 15 guarantees promised by Narendra Modi and his party. What’s the warranty on each guarantee? Judge for yourself.

1. Jobs: The BJP had promised to create “25 crore jobs” in their 2014 manifesto. In 2023, a Union minister admitted that only “1.2 crore jobs were created since 2014”. Reportedly, the minister referred to EPFO data to substantiate his claims on employment. As things stand, four out of ten graduates under the age of 25 are unemployed (‘State of Working India 2023’ report by Azim Premji University’s Centre for Sustainable Employment).

2. Doubling farmers’ income: Incomes needed to grow by 10 per cent year-on-year from 2015 in order to double by 2022. Actual growth has been only 3.5 per cent. At these growth rates, the guarantee will only be delivered in 2035. As per the latest NCRB data, the grim reality is that 30 farmers commit suicide every day.

(Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India 2022)

3. Demonetisation: Bringing back black money, curbing counterfeiting, stopping terrorism, ending corruption — all guarantees have failed. 99 per cent of the demonetised currency has come back into the system. This hare-brained scheme was nothing short of an act of economic terrorism.

4. Ujjwala scheme: As per reports, despite subsidies, over 1.2 crore households bought no refill cylinders at all in 2022-23. Another 1.5 crore beneficiaries bought only one refill cylinder.

5. Bullet Train: The project was announced in 2017. Since then, the deadline has been pushed several times.

6. Swachh Bharat Mission: In the last five years, 367 persons have died while undertaking hazardous cleaning of sewers and septic tanks (Lok Sabha, Unstarred Question No 440, replied on 05/12/2023, Annexure II). This is despite manual scavenging being banned in India since 2013.

7. Namami Gange: Pollution levels in the Ganga are higher than the levels recorded in 2014. More than half of the sewerage plant projects have been completed. According to the ‘Quantitative analysis of Microplastics along River Ganga’ study by Toxics Link in 2021, of the samples tested, the highest concentration of microplastic pollutants was found in Varanasi — which also happens to be the Prime Minister’s constituency.

8. Sagarmala Project: A port-led initiative to enhance India’s logistics sector. According to the Demands for Grants 2022-23 committee, out of the 44 projects in development, 31 projects had reportedly not received any funds.

9. PM Kisan: Rs 3,000 crore was transferred to 42 lakh ineligible farmers till 2021. The Union government recovered only one-tenth of the amount from fraudulent beneficiaries. (Rajya Sabha, Session 263, Unstarred Question No 12, Answered on 02/02/2024)

10. Atma Nirbhar Bharat: The scheme guaranteed Rs 3 lakh crore in collateral-free automatic loans to MSMEs. However, the reality is that only existing borrowers were targeted.

11. Digital India: There have been several Aadhar-based data breaches in recent years. Last year, the private data of 81 crore Indians was leaked to hackers on the dark web.

12. Railway infrastructure: 244 train accidents between 2017 and 2022. 15 major accidents in 2023 alone. Half of the compulsory track safety inspections were not completed. The Railway Budget has been subsumed under the Union Budget.

13. Nari-shakti: Until 2021, nearly 80 per cent of Beti Bachao Beti Padhao scheme funds were spent on advertising. In 2021-22, women labourers earned 60 per cent of what men did (‘Economic Growth, Structural Change, and Women’s Earnings in India’, CASI, University of Pennsylvania). 4,45,256 crimes occurred against women in 2022. This translates to 51 First Information Reports (FIRs) every hour. (NCRB Crime in India 2022)

14. Ude Desh Ka Aam Nagrik (UDAN): Of the 774 routes awarded under the aviation scheme UDAN-3, half could not initiate operations. Of the 371 routes that did start operations, only one-third could complete the three-year concession period. (CAG Report, Union Government (Civil), Ministry of Civil Aviation, No. 22 of 2023, (Compliance Audit), Para 3.1.1)

15. Hunger: Three out of four Indians cannot afford a healthy balanced diet. (The State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World 2023, FAO). Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana, a scheme started in response to COVID-19, had to be extended for five more years. As the number of billionaires increases manifold, 80 crore Indians are still dependent on free rations for their meals.

Modi guarantee. Zero warranty.

[This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, March 29, 2024]