It’s Time India’s Parliament Had A Calendar

by Derek O'Brien

The dates for the forthcoming Budget session of Parliament have been announced. Once again, at very short notice. We did some research and here is what we found. Historically, the Indian Parliament provided ample time for preparation. The first two Lok Sabhas (1952–1962) averaged a commendable 47 days between the time the notice was given, and the start of the session. Over the years, however, this gap has narrowed significantly. Under the current government, the average has plummeted to 17 days notice for summoning sessions—one of the lowest in the  history of independent India. This time around, the Parliamentary bulletin announcing the starting date (31 January) of the Budget Session, was announced on 17 January. Abysmal. 15 days notice!   

India’s Parliament has seen this troubling trend in the last two decades. The lack of proper planning hurts the functioning of a Parliamentary democracy. The diminishing lead time between the issuance of summons and the commencement of sessions is only one of the many ills that is ‘turning Parliament into a deep, dark chamber’. If schools and colleges can set up their calendars way in advance, why can’t Parliament? There are multiple advantages of preparing and then announcing a calendar for Parliament with sufficient lead time. Proper lead time will ensure higher quality of outputs from Members of Parliament (MPs). 

The Constitutional Gap

Unlike many other democracies, India does not have a fixed parliamentary calendar. Conventionally, Parliament meets for three sessions a year:

i. Budget Session (usually February-May),

ii. Monsoon Session (usually July-August), and

iii. Winter Session (usually November-December).

The only constitutional requirement is that there should not be more than six months between two sessions. The gap has enabled successive governments to carve out timing for sessions to suit themselves. This selfish tactic undermines the robustness of Parliament and raises serious questions. 

Can a Parliament that meets sporadically, with just two weeks notice, be an effective amplifier to voice concerns of citizens? Can a Parliament that gives MPs insufficient time to prepare, be a shining example of representative governance? Members of the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha are elected not just to legislate, but also to hold the government accountable, scrutinise its actions, and debate matters of national importance. These responsibilities will be fulfilled far better with a structured and predictable Parliamentary calendar.  

Efforts to address this issue go back many decades. In 1955, the General Purposes Committee of the Lok Sabha explored the idea of a fixed Parliamentary calendar. Then again in 2002, the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution, emphasised the need for a minimum number of sittings. Unfortunately, these proposals have still not been implemented.  

In 2019, your columnist introduced a Private Member’s Bill in Parliament to establish a fixed calendar for Parliamentary sessions and mandate a minimum of 100 sitting days annually. This aimed to enhance the functioning of Parliament by ensuring governments do not evade accountability by delaying sessions or cutting them short. A fixed schedule would allow Members of Parliament to plan their legislative and constituency responsibilities effectively, ensuring adequate time for debating and scrutinising bills, policies, and issues of public importance. By guaranteeing at least 100 sitting days, the bill sought to strengthen the democratic process, improve legislative efficiency, and uphold transparency and accountability in governance.

During the Constituent Assembly Debates, members like K.T. Shah argued that the flexibility of not having a fixed calendar should not lead to misuse, emphasising that Parliament must meet often to ensure proper oversight of the executive.India prides itself on being the world’s largest democracy. Yet, the strength of a democracy is measured not by its size but by the effectiveness of its institutions. Parliament is the cornerstone of this system, and its proper functioning is essential for ensuring that the voices of citizens are heard and their concerns addressed. A fixed Parliamentary calendar is not just a procedural reform, it will be a big step toward restoring some measure of the dignity and purpose of this institution.  

In countries like the UK and the US, Parliament and Congress have fixed session schedules. For instance, the UK House of Commons follows an annual calendar approved months in advance, ensuring MPs can prepare and balance their legislative and constituency duties.

This issue transcends political affiliations. It is about safeguarding the democratic framework and ensuring that Parliament fulfills its constitutional mandate. Seventy five years after adopting the Constitution, is as good a time as any, to give the world’s largest Parliamentary democracy a calendar with a well-planned schedule, and at least 100 days of Parliament being in session. 

Let’s get this done.

[This article was also published in NDTV| Monday, January 20, 2025]

Parliament Session: BJP Don’t Want To Answer Some Hard Questions

by Derek O'Brien

We are into the second week of the Winter Session of Parliament. The first week was washed out. MPs from Opposition parties, like the Trinamool Congress and the Samajwadi Party, are demanding ‘issues of national public importance’ be discussed on the floor of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha: price rise, unemployment, the situation in the North East and Manipur, states being deprived of funds by the Union government, and violence in Sambhal, Uttar Pradesh, among others. The principal Opposition party, the Congress, wants a discussion on the alleged financial irregularities of the Adani group. Deadlock.  

At the time of writing this article, there is news that the deadlock between the Opposition and the Union government has been broken. Media reports suggest that in exchange for a discussion on the Constitution to be taken up in mid-December (almost two weeks from now), the government and the Opposition will ensure Parliament functions smoothly. I find this ludicrous.    

How can you come to an understanding on December 2, about what will be discussed in mid-December on the floor of Parliament! What will happen in the interim? If an agreement has indeed been reached between the government and the Opposition, why wait for two weeks to implement it? Start the discussion this week itself. The Modi-led NDA coalition is being too clever by half.  

Let me put it straight up. It is the Union government that does not want Parliament to function. But do not take the view of this Opposition MP seriously. Here is what two BJP stalwarts had said about the functioning of Parliament:

“Parliament’s job is to conduct discussions. But many a time, Parliament is used to ignore issues and in such situations, obstruction of Parliament is in the favour of democracy.” – Arun Jaitley, 2011.  

“It is the government’s job to run the Parliament, not that of the opposition.” – Sushma Swaraj, 2012.

Disgraceful Record In Parliament

Even when Parliament functions, what is the track record of Mr Narendra Modi in the last decade. Consider this:

  1.  In the 15th Lok Sabha (2009-14), seven out of 10 Bills were sent to committees for scrutiny, in the 7th LS (2019-24), only two out of 10 Bills were sent for scrutiny.
  2. Nine out of 10 bills introduced in Parliament were marked by zero or incomplete consultations in the 17th LS.
  3. A total of 221 Bills were passed, of which over one-third were hurried through with less than a 60-minute discussion.
  4. No Deputy Leader was elected in Lok Sabha for the entirety of 17th LS. The current Lok Sabha still has no Deputy Leader.
  5. In the last eight years, not a single notice by a member of the Opposition has been accepted for discussion under Rule 267 in Rajya Sabha.
  6. The Prime Minister has not answered a single question on the floor of Parliament.

With such a disgraceful track record, it is not surprising that the ruling dispensation is trying to turn Parliament into a deep, dark chamber and choke the Opposition.  

Let us now handle the second issue in the headlines: the demand to set up a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC). A JPC only looks good on paper. Its very structure and track record suggests that it is most unlikely to deliver meaningful results, especially when the ruling dispensation enjoys a dominant majority in Parliament.  

Ruling Party Dominates The JPC

The composition of the JPC is determined by the strength of parties in Parliament. With the NDA’s majority in both Houses, any JPC formed today would be dominated by members loyal to the ruling party.

The chairperson, almost certainly a BJP MP, would steer the proceedings. Key decisions, from selecting witnesses to approving reports, would be controlled by the Treasury benches. This compromises the credibility of the entire process and makes the ruling dispensation a judge in their own case.

No Consensus, Only Dissent

JPCs rarely reach consensus on their reports. Opposition members are almost always outvoted by the majority. Any dissenting views are reduced to a footnote in the final report, which rubber-stamps the ruling party’s narrative.

Here are some examples. During the Bofors case, the committee, chaired by B. Shankaranand, was formed in 1987. It held 50 sittings and submitted its report in 1988. The committee concluded that there was no evidence of any violation of Indian law concerning the Bofors payments. However, it faced a boycott from Opposition members.  

For the Harshad Mehta scam in 1992, a committee was constituted following the discovery of irregularities in banking and securities transactions at the State Bank of India. The committee held 96 sittings and submitted its report in which included 273 recommendations. The report failed to address systemic market

issues, leaving room for future financial scandals. Of the 273 recommendations, the government accepted only 87 in its action taken report, presented in July 1994.

In many such instances, including the Ketan Parekh scam in 2001, Opposition members either boycotted or dissented from the final JPC reports because they were biased towards the ruling party.

Recommendations Go Nowhere

Even when JPCs make good recommendations, they are often ignored. The 2001 JPC on the stock market scam suggested stronger regulations, but many of its proposals were diluted or ignored. The 2011 JPC on spectrum allocation saw its findings mired in controversy, with little meaningful reform.

Bread and butter issues need to be discussed this Winter Session of Parliament. Why are the prices of onions, tomatoes, and garlic so high? Why are four out of ten youth unemployed? Why are States who oppose the BJP deliberately penalised? Why is Prime Minister Modi so skittish about visiting Manipur? These are just some of the hard questions the BJP refuses to answer on the floor of Parliament.  

[This article was also published in NDTV| Tuesday, December 3, 2024]

When Parliament isn’t in session, standing committees are where the action is

by Derek O'Brien

135 down to 55! The average number of days Parliament sits annually has gone down from 135 days in the first Lok Sabha to 55 days in the 17th Lok Sabha (2019-24). So what happens during the remaining 300 days? Standing Committees, which consider and report on Demand for Grants, Bills, annual reports, and discuss national basic long-term policy documents of the concerned department/ministries, are where most of the action takes place when Parliament is not in session. Unfortunately, these committees have been undermined by governments not open to deliberation and debate.

After much delay, the 24 Departmentally Related Standing Committees (DRSC) were recently reconstituted and their chairpersons appointed. Each DRSC consists of 31 members from across parties, 21 from Lok Sabha and 10 from Rajya Sabha. In the last few weeks, these committees have started holding their first meetings. (Just to clarify, the intense deliberations on the Waqf Bill are taking place in a Joint Parliamentary Committee — not to be confused with a DRSC.) As we go to press, there are conflicting opinions on whether regulatory bodies like SEBI can come under the scrutiny of the Public Accounts Committee.

Despite all the activity, Standing Committees are not performing as they are mandated to. Take the Committee on Social Justice and Empowerment: It oversees three vital ministries — Minority Affairs, Tribal Affairs, and Social Justice and Empowerment. Yet, in 2023, some MPs attended only one or two of its 16 meetings. Only two out of 24 committees are chaired by women. The Standing Committee on Women Empowerment, an administrative committee to recommend measures to improve the status of women, has not yet been constituted for the 18th Lok Sabha. The Departmentally Related Standing Committee on Education, Women, Children, Youth, and Sports hasn’t had a woman chairperson in the last two decades.

In the 15th Lok Sabha, seven out of 10 bills were sent to committees for scrutiny. Fast forward to the 17th Lok Sabha, and that number dropped to just one out of five. Bills are now wrapped up in an average of only nine sittings, with the three Criminal Law Bills discussed together in just 12 sittings. For committees to be taken seriously, their reports need to be regularly tabled and discussed in Parliament. The Committee on Papers Laid on The Table has repeatedly flagged ongoing delays in tabling reports. In 2018, the Committee on External Affairs had its findings on the Doklam issue stalled for months due to opposition from MPs of the ruling dispensation.

When asked if committee recommendations should be made binding on the government, former Lok Sabha Speaker and legendary Parliamentarian Somnath Chatterjee replied, “No, they should not. But I would like the government to give good reasons for not accepting a recommendation.” Your columnist thinks it is time for an overhaul. Here are five specific suggestions.

One: According to the rules, the government is required to respond to committee recommendations within six months. This should be brought down to 60 days, as practised in the British House of Commons.

Two: MPs serve in committees for just a year, leading to constant reshuffling and lack of expertise. Take a cue from the US Congress’ permanent Standing Committees or Kerala’s Legislative Assembly, with a 30-month tenure. A longer tenure will work better.

Three: A Parliamentary Committee on National Economy should be formed to annually examine the state of the economy. Short-duration discussions should be initiated in both Houses of Parliament to discuss the reports. This should be followed by a response from the Minister. Public borrowing, as it affects future governments, should also be reviewed by this committee.

Four: In a federal democracy, the responsibility of the Parliament while passing Constitution Amendment Bills is immense. Therefore, a Constitution Committee should be established for prior scrutiny to check if these are ultra vires to the Constitution, and strengthen the credibility of constitutional amendments.

Five: Pre-budget scrutiny and proper examination of Demand for Grants (DFGs) must not be sidelined because of elections. Following the constitution of Lok Sabhas in 2014, 2019, and 2024, DFGs were not sent to Standing Committees. The precedent set in the 11th Lok Sabha (1996) should be followed. The Union Budget was presented on July 22. The House adjourned on August 2 and was reconvened on August 26, for committees to review the Demand for Grants.

P.S. Some observers suggest that proceedings of committee meetings should be telecast live on Sansad TV, just as Parliamentary proceedings are. Not a good idea. Why? That is a subject for another column.

[This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, October 25, 2024]

The entire Monsoon Session of Parliament washed out by Union govt

by Derek O'Brien

When Parliament doesn’t function, who benefits? Govt in power. Govt accountable to Parliament;
Parliament accountable to people;
When Parliament is dysfunctional, govt accountable to no one

Question: When Parliament does not function or is disrupted, who is the biggest beneficiary?

Answer: The government in power.

The logic is straightforward. One, the government is accountable to Parliament; two, Parliament is accountable to the people; three, when Parliament is dysfunctional, the government is not accountable to anyone!

The total time scheduled for the upcoming session of Parliament is 190 hours. Here is how this time is divided between the government and the Opposition. About half the questions for Question Hour and half the number of notices for Zero Hour are filed by Opposition MPs. This adds up to 31 hours for members of the Opposition to raise questions and matters of public importance. In comparison, the Union government gets 135 hours out of the total 190 for government business and other issues — a whopping 70 per cent of the total time.

There is a legitimate need to cut down on the hours available to the government. Allot some more time to the Opposition. Four hours must be reserved each week, in each House, to allow discussions on matters of urgent public importance. Additionally, two hours should also be reserved for a Calling Attention motion (here the MP brings a matter of urgent public importance to the relevant Minister’s notice who is mandated to reply). This will give the Opposition an added six hours each week in both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha to raise important issues of national public importance. This would mean about 117 hours for government business and 49 hours for the Opposition. A much fairer system.

In recent years, several critical legislative decisions have been made without adequately hearing out the Opposition. For instance, the farm Bills initially came as an ordinance, and were not sent to the department-related parliamentary standing committees or the select committee of the Rajya Sabha for scrutiny, as the Opposition requested. Passed by voice vote in the Rajya Sabha, Opposition demands for a vote were ignored. Ultimately, these laws had to be repealed.

Notably, in the 17th Lok Sabha, a total of 221 Bills were passed. More than one-third were hurried through with less than a 60-minute discussion. Only one out of six Bills was scrutinised by Committees. Even the ones that made it to the committees were handled casually. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023,

which proposes a sweeping overhaul of the criminal justice system with 356 amendments, along with the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita and Bharatiya Sakshya Bill were all discussed in merely 13 sittings. In comparison, the Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Bill, 2006, with its 41 amendments, was scrutinised by the Home Affairs Committee over 11 sittings.

Another recent issue that saw minimal participation from the Opposition was the “discussion” on the Parliament security breach. In 2001, when Parliament was attacked, both houses of Parliament engaged in a comprehensive discussion involving the Prime Minister and the Home Minister. This inclusive dialogue demonstrated a commitment to addressing security concerns collaboratively and transparently. However, in stark contrast, in 2023, when Parliament security was breached, 146 Opposition MPs were suspended for demanding a discussion on the subject.

The Provisional Collection of Taxes Bill 2023 was debated by only two and six members and passed in approximately 21 and 30 minutes in Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, respectively. Similarly, the Telecommunications Bill saw participation from merely four and eight members and was passed in one hour four minutes and within an hour in Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, respectively. Many other Bills have met the same fate: The Jan Vishwas Bill, the Digital Personal Data Protection Bill, Government of NCT of Delhi (Amendment) Bill etc.

Between September 2020 and August 2021, 113 notices were filed by MPs in the Lok Sabha for Short Duration Discussion. Only two were accepted. Not allowing notices for a debate on matters of urgent public importance is the most lethal device to muzzle the voice of the Opposition in Parliament. The presiding officers, in their wisdom, would do well to address this.

The re-allotment of time in Parliament between the government and the Opposition needs to be seriously looked at. This is not merely a procedural adjustment, but a fundamental necessity to uphold the principles of accountability and representative democracy.

[This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, July 19, 2024]

Here’s An Unlikely Combination: Narendra Modi and Billy Joel

by Derek O'Brien

In the last ten years (2014-2024), Mr Modi has done all it takes to turn Parliament into a deep dark chamber. Early in 2024, after a long gap of 30 years, one of my fave singer-songwriters, the legendary Billy Joel, released a new song titled Turn the Lights Back On.

That’s the verdict after India Elections 2024. The Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha must not be allowed to be turned into a deep, dark chamber. Turn the Lights Back On.

Let’s get this done.

1. Parliament Calendar

    Introduce a fixed calendar for the three sessions of Parliament with a minimum of 100 days of sittings a year for each House. The number of sittings per year for Lok Sabha has reduced from an average of 121 days (1952-1970) to 70 days per year since 2000. In 2019, your columnist introduced a Private Member’s Bill seeking a fixed calendar for Parliament sessions and a minimum number of sittings of 100 days.

    2. Deputy Speaker In Lok Sabha

      Article 93 of the Constitution says that the Lok Sabha shall choose two members of the House as Speaker and Deputy Speaker as soon as the case may be. The 17th Lok Sabha did not have a Deputy Speaker for its entire five-year term. The Deputy Speaker is not subordinate to the Speaker. The Speaker has to tender his resignation to the Deputy Speaker if s/he chooses to do so. Traditionally, the Deputy Speaker is appointed from the Opposition. The Deputy Speaker should be appointed in this session itself.

      3. Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy

        Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy was adopted in 2014 to ensure public consultation for all legislation. In the 17th Lok Sabha, nine out of 10 bills introduced in Parliament have been marked by zero or incomplete consultations. Each Minister, while introducing a Bill, should lay a copy of the summary of the consultations.

        4. Scrutiny Of Bills

          In the 14th Lok Sabha, six out of 10 bills were sent to various committees for scrutiny; in the 15th Lok Sabha, it was seven out of 10. This figure fell in the 16th Lok Sabha to four out of 10. In the 17th Lok Sabha, about one out of five bills was sent for scrutiny. Abysmal. The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002) recommended that all bills introduced in Parliament should first be examined by the relevant committee. Committees should also review the implementation of laws passed by Parliament.

          5. Constitution Amendment Bills

            A joint constitutional committee from both Houses should be formed to review the constitutional validity of Constitution Amendment Bills before they are introduced.

            6. Admit 267 Notice In Rajya Sabha

              Rule 267 gives Rajya Sabha MPs an opportunity to give a written notice to suspend regular business and seek an immediate discussion on an issue of national importance. It has been eight years since such a discussion has been permitted. At least one such notice should be admitted in each session.

              7. Active Participation Of PM

                The Prime Minister has not answered a single question on the floor of Parliament. His participation has been limited to monologues – speeches during Motion of Thanks, farewells, and special occasions. Narendra Modi needs to answer questions, take part in debates and discussions on national issues. (The UK Parliament has Prime Minister’s Question Time every Wednesday where it is mandatory for the PM to answer.)

                8. Joint Parliamentary Committee On Security

                  Following the Parliament security breach last year, the Committee on security in Parliament house complex should be reconstituted immediately, with the Deputy Speaker as the Chairperson.

                  9. Committee On National Economy

                    A Parliamentary Committee on National Economy should be formed to produce annual reports on the state of the economy. The report should then be discussed in Parliament. The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002) noted that there is no system for Parliamentary scrutiny of public borrowing. Since it affects future governments, beyond certain limits, borrowing proposals should also be reviewed by the Parliamentary Committee on National Economy.

                    10. Technical Expertise for Committees

                      Funds should be allocated to provide research support staff to committees to conduct public hearings, inquiries, and collect data. Currently, the secretariat assists with scheduling meetings and taking notes. The quality of output will improve if each committee is assigned a team dedicated to research.

                      Please open the door

                      Nothing is different, we’ve been here before

                      Pacing these halls

                      Trying to talk over the silence

                      And pride sticks out its tongue

                      Laughs at the portrait that we’ve become

                      Stuck in a frame, unable to change

                      I was wrong

                      Did I wait too long

                      To turn the lights back on?

                      – Billy Joel, Turn the Lights Back On.

                      [This article was also published in NDTV | Friday, June 28, 2024]

                      New Parliament should get rid of bad laws

                      by Derek O'Brien

                      Narendra Modi’s BJP ran the government in India for 10 years. That government has been rejected. So we have a new starting point going forward. As Parliament is reconstituted after the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, let’s be straight up. The following laws should be reconsidered and repealed to ensure justice, equality, liberty for all citizens.

                      Citizenship Amendment Act: As the Citizenship Amendment Bill was introduced in Parliament in 2019, the country protested over concerns that coupled with the proposed National Register of Citizens (NRC), it could lead to the disenfranchisement of many Indian citizens. Home Minister Amit Shah’s insistence that the NRC would be implemented nationwide, despite the disastrous pilot project in Assam — where around 6 per cent of residents were left out of the final NRC list — exacerbated these concerns. If this exclusion rate is extrapolated nationally, crores of Indians could potentially become stateless.

                      Criminal Law Bills: The recent arbitrarily-enacted Criminal Law Bills, require urgent reconsideration and repeal since they encompass the provisions on marital rape and sedition, and pose the risk of “police raj” by criminalising “resisting, refusing, ignoring or disregarding to conform to any direction given by a police officer”. This is a slippery slope to authoritarianism and undermines fundamental freedoms. The devil is in the details. These laws, with their significant discrepancies and inherent injustices, need thorough scrutiny and stakeholder consultations. (This columnist was a member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Home Affairs where constructive suggestions and voices of dissent from members of the Opposition were ignored in the final recommendations.)

                      Marital Rape Exception: Section 63 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita deals with the offence of rape but provides an exception for marital rape, stating that “sexual intercourse or sexual acts by a man with his own wife, the wife not being under eighteen years of age, is not rape”. This exception stems from archaic English laws that did not recognise men and women as equals. It undermines the fundamental principle that rape is a violation of personal autonomy and bodily integrity, regardless of the relationship between the perpetrator and the victim. It’s high time we bid farewell to this outdated notion.

                      Sedition: The use of Section 124A of the IPC (the old sedition law) had been kept in abeyance following a Supreme Court order in May 2022. The court had given the government time to reconsider the law. Subsequently, the Home Minister claimed that sedition has been removed from the list of offences in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. This new version avoids the term “sedition” but introduces the vaguely-defined offence of “endangering the sovereignty, unity, and integrity of India”. This broad definition, contrary to the 22nd Law Commission’s recommendation for clarity, leaves room for misuse and threatens to stifle dissent and protest.

                      The Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners Act, 2023: The Act changes the composition of the selection committee to appoint Election Commissioners. The Supreme Court’s directive that the Chief Justice should be a part of the Committee was disregarded. The Prime Minister, Leader of the Opposition (Lok Sabha), and a nominated Union cabinet minister now make the selection, giving the Union government total control over the selection.

                      The Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Act, 2023: The Act empowered the Union government to exclusively auction mining leases and composite exploration licences for certain critical high-value minerals such as cadmium, selenium, nickel, cobalt, tin, etc. It also dispensed with the forest clearances required for mine reconnaissance and prospecting operations. It is critical to point out that the Act allows sub-surface excavation as part of reconnaissance, which had been prohibited under the 1957 Act. The environmental consequences of such invasive operations can be severe and irreversible, undermining sustainable development goals and disregarding previously existing environmental protections.

                      The Transgender Persons Act, 2019: The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, only recognises “sexual abuse” with a maximum punishment of two years as opposed to life imprisonment for rape of women. This punishment is insufficient and discriminatory. The law on rape should be inclusive and extend its protection to transgender women, ensuring they receive the same legal safeguards and justice as cisgender women.

                      The Aircraft Act, 1934: The law defines an aircraft as “any machine which can derive support in the atmosphere from reactions of the air”. It includes “balloons, whether fixed or free, airships, kites, gliders and flying machines”. So, yes, your childhood kite is basically an aircraft, and your backyard might just be an aerodrome!

                      [This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, June 21, 2024]

                      Let Young MPs Light Up Parliament Which Has Become a “Deep, Dark Chamber”

                      by Derek O'Brien

                      Very happy with the news that Swati Maliwal, the young firebrand chief of the Delhi Commission for Women (DCW), has been nominated by the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) as a candidate for election to Rajya Sabha. Maliwal (39), when elected, will be part of a small group of young MPs in Rajya Sabha who are in their 30s and early 40s.

                      This includes Jebi Mather from the Congress, AAP’s Raghav Chadha (35), and three of my colleagues from the Trinamool Congress.

                      One is Saket Gokhale (36), among India’s foremost RTI activists, who has also faced incarceration for his activism. There’s Prakash Chik Baraik (42) a popular and rising tribal leader from the Alipurduars who comes from a humble background of tea estate workers. More young blood. Meet Samirul Islam (36) an alumnus of IIT Delhi who spent a short while overseas and then gave it all up to come back to India and work at the grassroots for the welfare of the socially challenged, especially migrant workers.

                      Then there’s the plucky Jebi Mather of the Congress from Kerala who is an advocate, a former Municipal Councillor and, astonishingly, the first woman Rajya Sabha MP from Kerala in the last 42 years.

                      These young colleagues of mine have entered Rajya Sabha with a great amount of hope and with the determination to excel in their responsibilities as parliamentarians. Whenever I chat with them, I am glad to see their enthusiasm and their faith in parliamentary procedure.

                      Let these young people do all it takes to light up an institution that is being turned into a deep, dark chamber.

                      No place for disagreements

                      In 1987, the Chairman of Rajya Sabha emphasised, “Every member is entitled to express his opinion. Merely because you disagree, you cannot shut him down. Then, there will be no parliament.”

                      Between 2019-2023, MPs faced suspension on multiple occasions, marking a 13-fold increase from the 15th Lok Sabha (2009-2014). Compare that to MPs from the ruling dispensation. Despite allegations of sexual harassment, use of toxic communal slurs on the floor of the House, and enabling a security breach in parliament, no action has been taken against any of them. No BJP MP has faced suspension in the last 10 years.

                      Quality of Committees

                      Parliamentary committees play a vital role by taking up crucial policy matters for discussion, inviting participation from stakeholders and domain experts. Consider this. The Home Affairs Committee while analysing the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) Bill, 2006, which had 41 amendments, sat for 11 sittings. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023, one of the three Bills overhauling the entire criminal justice system, with 356 amendments (almost nine times that of the CrPC Bill) was discussed in just 13 sittings.

                      Bulldozing Legislation

                      Former leader of Rajya Sabha, N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar, stressed in the Constituent Assembly that the purpose of a second chamber is to conduct dignified debates, delaying impulsive and hasty legislation. Significant Bills like the 1977 Banking Service Commission Repeal Bill and the 2002 Prevention of Terrorism Bill were passed in Lok Sabha but rejected by Rajya Sabha.

                      In the last winter session, 47% of Opposition MPs were suspended for demanding a discussion and statement from the Home Minister on the parliament security breach. As a result, the discussion on the Provisional Collection of Taxes Bill saw participation by just six members and was passed in 30 minutes. The Telecommunications Bill saw only eight members taking part in the discussion and was passed in an hour. The three critical Criminal Law Bills were passed in five hours, with the Home Minister himself speaking for an hour. Since 2019, over 100 Bills have been passed in less than two hours.

                      Stealth and Secrecy

                      Rule 69 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Council of States (Rajya Sabha) states that a Bill should be circulated to MPs two days before it is taken up for consideration. Though the Chairman has discretionary power, this was a long established practice that had become convention.

                      Today, secrecy reigns supreme. Take the case of the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Bill, 2019, which stripped J&K of its statehood. The Supplementary List of Business reached the members at 11:18 am, while the Bill was introduced at 11:07 am. It was discussed and passed on the very same day.

                      Not House of Elders, but Council of States

                      The Council of States, unlike the House of Lords in the UK, was designed to genuinely deliberate and represent states and their interests. A notable instance of this occurred in 1989 when Rajya Sabha rejected the Nagarpalika Bill passed by the Rajiv Gandhi government. The Opposition in Rajya Sabha perceived it as a threat to the federal structure of the country.

                      Post 2014, there has been a paradigm shift. The Opposition has been systematically targeted, from muting microphones and blacking out live feed, to outright suspension. The principles of federalism have been trampled upon. Bills aimed at weakening state governments such as the J&K Reorganisation Bill, 2023 and the Government of NCT of Delhi (Amendment) Bill, 2023 were passed in less than half a day.

                      In March 2016, the Prime Minister had stated in the Rajya Sabha, “This is the Upper House. Whatever happens in this House, its impact is felt on Lok Sabha, Assemblies and Municipal Corporations. So we should think how to create an atmosphere by which democracy can be strengthened.”

                      [This article was also published in NDTV | Friday, January 12, 2024]

                      How BJP has made a mockery of democracy

                      by Derek O'Brien

                      The first three days of the new year witnessed a massive strike by truck drivers across northern and western India. Petrol pumps started running out of fuel, there was panic buying, and prices of vegetables and milk skyrocketed. The truckers and their owners were protesting one of the provisions in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (one of the three new criminal Acts bulldozed recently in Parliament). The Union Home Secretary finally pulled the hand-brake on the provision in the bill that called for stringent penalties in hit-and-run cases.

                      Cowboy legislation

                      This is symptomatic of a larger malaise. Legislate first, discuss later. Your columnist has often called this “Cowboy Legislation”.

                      The disaster that was demonetisation. A nation locked down for Covid with just four hours notice. Three farm laws irresponsibly passed and then forced to be withdrawn because of a powerful movement. Or, take 2017, when GST was hastily implemented ignoring warnings. Thereafter, 129 amendments and 741 notifications related to GST have had to be issued in five years. The Data Protection Act of 2023 was passed after only 52 minutes and 67 minutes of debate with only nine and seven MPs taking part in the discussion in Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, respectively. The latest example of Modi and Shah’s “cowboy legislation” is the three criminal law bills which mocked Parliamentary democracy.

                      All this recklessness impacts, more than anyone else, the marginalised. Consider this: After five years in prison, 121 tribals accused in the 2017 Burkapal Naxal attack were acquitted by the NIA court citing lack of evidence. They were able to attend court only twice during the trial, in spite of the mandatory in-person appearance. As per the Prison Statistics of India Report 2021, 77 per cent of the total prison population are undertrials. Three out of five undertrial prisoners lodged across Indian prisons are from the Dalit, Adivasi and OBC communities.

                      This serves as a stark reminder of the systemic flaws within India’s criminal justice framework which predate any proposed amendments. Two of my learned colleagues in the Home Affairs standing committee which examined the criminal law bills for almost three months, P Chidambaram (INC), N R Elango (DMK), along with your columnist, submitted comprehensive dissent notes. The notes red-flagged against the implementation of more stringent laws that could exacerbate the current injustices.

                      Lack of diversity

                      The first draft of the three criminal law bills was made by the Ranbir Singh Committee. The committee was composed entirely of men from similar social, professional, and economic backgrounds and experience. It lacked representation from various marginalised groups, including women, Dalits, religious minorities, Adivasis, LGBTQs, and persons with disabilities. The absence of diverse perspectives was a significant concern, particularly when addressing matters of such magnitude and societal impact.

                      Disregard for procedure and skewed stakeholder consultation

                      The ruling dispensation has a brute majority in the Home Affairs standing committee. Little wonder, dissent notes from Opposition MPs notwithstanding, it was nothing but a parliamentary rubber-stamping committee. Those consulted were from an extremely limited and mostly homogeneous group of stakeholders. Accomplished legal superstars like Justice U U Lalit, Madan Lokur and others were not called in to testify. (It must be mentioned that one of the heads of the BJP legal cell made the cut).

                      The pre-legislative consultation policy of 2014 mandates a 30-day consultation period with the general public before a law can be approved by the cabinet for introduction in Parliament.

                      This consultation process, which involves sharing the draft with the public, must be accompanied by: (i) Explanations for its enactment, (ii) Financial considerations, and (iii) An evaluation of the law’s potential impact. Moreover, the comments received during the consultation should be made available on the ministry’s website.

                      In the case of these Criminal Law Bills, however, a committee was formed with its members and objectives shrouded in secrecy, shielding it from public scrutiny. There exists a notable absence of a clear and compelling rationale for why such a substantial reform was undertaken. Especially since the Home Minister himself stated in Parliament that the primary objective was to alter a few specific sections of the law.

                      Eliminating the Opposition

                      The laws were rashly amended to incorporate draconian definitions of sedition, disregard for special statutes, rape not being gender neutral, extensive police custody, and who can be branded a terrorist. The Bills were passed in an almost empty House, as the government had suspended 146 Opposition MPs. These MPs represented 34 crore people, 25 per cent of India’s population. Parliament has been turned into a deep, dark chamber.

                      We are all for reform. Who can be against reform? But in the name of reform, let us not become more repressive than the colonisers. While there is an undeniable need to reform the colonial era criminal framework, the current criminal law Acts will treat citizens worse than how “native subjects” of the Raj were dealt with.

                      [This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, January 05, 2024]