Fluid Friendships: Over A Quarter Of BJP Candidates Are Defectors

by Derek O'Brien

One out of four BJP candidates in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections are defectors from other parties. An analysis of the 417 candidates announced shows that 116 of them, that is 28%, have switched sides to join the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). The highest number of such defectors, 37, are from the Indian National Congress.

In Indian politics, the phrase ‘Aya Ram Gaya Ram’ is often used to describe politicians who frequently switch parties. The story goes that Gaya Lal, an MLA from Hodal, Haryana, won the election as an independent candidate in 1967 and joined the Congress. Thereafter, he changed parties thrice in 15 days.

Between 1967 and 1983, there were approximately 2,700 defections at the state level. As many as 15 defectors went on to become chief ministers. This high number of defections led to the enactment of the Anti-Defection Law, the 52nd Amendment Act of 1985.

Even though the anti-defection law is in place, it is very easy to circumvent it. The Supreme Court’s rulings on this matter have also not been enough to curb the malaise. Politicians now often resign from their original party, instead of formally ‘crossing the floor’ or voting against their party in a confidence motion. This sidesteps the law, while bringing down the party’s strength in the House.

An analysis of 433 MPs and MLAs who changed parties and re-contested elections held between 2016 and 2020 shows that out of 405 MLAs who switched political parties, 182, almost 45%, joined the BJP. Out of 16 Rajya Sabha MPs who switched political parties, 10, that is over 60%, joined the BJP.

Here are five instances from recent history where democratically elected state governments have been toppled through defections.

1. Karnataka

A party or coalition needs 113 seats for a majority in the 224-member state assembly. The Congress and the Janata Dal (Secular) (JD-S) formed a coalition government in 2018 with 115 MLAs. However, 13 MLAs of the Congress and three MLAs of the JD(S) resigned within 14 months, reducing the strength of the House to 208, and the majority mark came down to 105 seats. The BJP, which had exactly 105 MLAs, proved its majority and formed the next government.

2. Madhya Pradesh

The fall of the Kamal Nath-led government started with the resignation of Jyotiraditya Scindia from his seat in Parliament. Following this, MLAs loyal to Scindia, including six ministers, resigned. This led to the toppling of the Congress government in the state and paved the way for the formation of the Shivraj Singh Chouhan-led BJP government. Scindia was awarded by being made a minister in the Union cabinet.

3. Manipur

In the 2017 Manipur Assembly Elections, the Congress won 28 seats and the BJP 21. The majority mark in the 60-member House is 31. The BJP and its allies together had 30 seats. The BJP got a single Congress MLA to form the government. Later, eight other Congress MLAs lent their ‘unofficial’ support to the BJP. The Congress MLAs who supported the BJP never actually resigned from the Congress or issued letters of support for the BJP-led government. They even continued sitting in the Opposition benches to avoid violating the anti-defection law.

4. Arunachal Pradesh

After forming the government in 2014, Congress Chief Minister Pema Khandu took 43 of his party MLAs with him in 2016 and joined the People’s Party of Arunachal (PPA), which was in alliance with the BJP. By the end of that year, 33 PPA MLAs joined the BJP and formed the government. Later, two more Congress MLAs defected to the BJP. Within a span of one year, mass defections brought the number of Congress MLAs down from 47 to just one.

5. Maharashtra

In 2019, the BJP won 105 seats, followed by the Shiv Sena with 56, the NCP 54 and the Congress 44. The majority mark in the 288-member House is 145. The BJP and the Shiv Sena were to form the government; however, they had a falling out. When the possibility of a non-BJP government was imminent, President’s Rule was imposed in the state. On November 23, 2019, at 5.47 a.m., the Union government invoked Rule 12 of the Transaction of Business Rules, 1961, which empowered it to revoke the proclamation of President’s Rule in Maharashtra without the prior approval of the Union Cabinet. This allowed the BJP a chance to form the government when it briefly gained the support of Ajit Pawar.

The resultant government lasted just 80 hours. Ajit Pawar and Fadnavis resigned. This led to the formation of a coalition government comprising the Shiv Sena, the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) and the Congress. In June 2022, a Shiv Sena member, Eknath Shinde, with two-thirds of the Shiv Sena MLAs, revoked support to the Uddhav Thackeray government and claimed to be the real Shiv Sena. Shinde and his MLAs then formed a government in coalition with the BJP, with former chief minister Fadnavis as his deputy.

These incidents highlight the urgent need to reassess the existing anti-defection law and give it more teeth. Blatant subversion of people’s mandates must come to a stop.

[This article was also published in NDTV | Monday, April 15, 2024]

2024, the election year, the conflict year

by Derek O'Brien

This is the first time that Mexico could get a woman president. Joe Biden is seeking a second term in the United States. The Democratic People’s Party in Taiwan has just won a historic third consecutive term. The fourth most populous country in the world, Indonesia, will elect a new President soon. Sheikh Hasina has won a fifth term in Bangladesh.

In 2024, national elections are scheduled in over 60 countries. Two billion voters will cast their votes. That’s a quarter of the world’s population.

This is a “super election year”. Election booths will be buzzing in the United States, the United Kingdom, India and Indonesia. Psephologists and political enthusiasts will gleefully witness the dynamics of power, democracy, and unpredictability as elections play out on a global scale. Those suffering from politicophobia (a morbid fear of politics and voting) would prefer to fast forward to 2025.

One dominant theme emerges from elections being held across the globe this year — societal divisions have been laid bare. From the deeply polarising issue of abortion rights to the contentious debate over corporatisation in agriculture, the fault lines are stark. Many of these elections, including India’s, are not just about choosing leaders; they are about deciding the direction of societies ruptured by conflicting ideologies.

United Kingdom: Bookmakers’ odds are often dependable barometers to predict results in sport and politics. Even though elections in the UK are expected to be held in the latter half of 2024, British bookmakers have virtually already called the result. According to Ladbrokes, one of England’s oldest betting companies, the Labour Party, led by Keir Starmer, are clear favourites to win, with odds of 1/10. To give you some sense of what 1/10 odds mean, let me share a similar example from cricket.

If India is playing Afghanistan in a T20 match, India will probably start at the odds of 1/10 — favourites to win. In other words, if you invest £1,000 on the Labour Party winning, you only stand to gain £100. So, as far as the bookmakers are concerned, it’s pretty much a done deal for the Labour Party. In contrast, the Conservative Party led by Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, has odds of 6/1. What this means is that a £1,000 bet on the Conservative Party will earn a huge £6,000 if the Conservatives win. The populist right-wing party Reform UK (earlier Brexit party), led by Richard Tice, are a distant third with odds of 50/1. It must be pointed out that there are multiple examples where favourites bite the dust.

United States: Trump versus Biden rematch. The economy, cost of living, LGBTQ rights, the war in Ukraine, and conflict in Gaza are some of the hot-button issues which are dominating political debate on American television. From campaign rallies to made-for-television debates, one flashpoint is certainly abortion rights.

The seismic 2021 overturning of Roe v. Wade and the Alabama Supreme Court’s controversial decision equating frozen embryos with children have intensified the cultural chasm between conservative and liberal states. Abortion has surged to the forefront of political discourse, with one in eight voters deeming it critical. Research indicates a doubling since 2020 in patients travelling for abortions, with medical abortions now exceeding half of all procedures.

These have had a profound impact on reproductive rights, stirring voter mobilisation and accentuating enduring ideological divisions. As both the controversial Donald Trump and the octogenarian President Biden line up on the starting blocks for second terms, abortion rights might determine who crosses the finishing line first.

South Africa: In a historic shift post-apartheid, South Africa’s upcoming general election on May 29 could see the African National Congress (ANC) receiving less than 50 per cent of the vote for the first time since 1994. I am no psephologist, but this could lead to a multi-party government, marking a significant moment for South Africans and the region.

India: The last five years have seen the country set many dubious records. Household savings have been at a 50-year low. Three out of four Indians cannot afford a healthy balanced diet. Four out of 10 graduates under the age of 25 are unemployed. Women earn just 60 per cent as compared to their male counterparts. And the Press Freedom Index ranks India 161 among 180 countries. These are the issues which the ruling dispensation will obfuscate. These are the issues which opposition parties across the country will need to amplify. These are the issues which television channels turned cheerleaders will ignore over the next six weeks.

Instead, the Union government will attempt to create a narrative around two laws — the Citizenship (Amendment) Act and the Women’s Reservation Bill. You don’t have to be a Parliament junkie to know that the timing is suspect. Consider these: While the average time taken to frame rules for a law is nine months, the rules for CAA were notified after 51 months (over four years). The Union government had asked for nine extensions. Then there was the Women’s Reservation Bill, passed in Parliament, but which can only be implemented after the Census and delimitation is carried out. 2034?

As the world’s largest democracy goes to elections in the summer of 2024, women’s political representation will only be limited to the glossy sheets of a slickly printed manifesto.

[This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, March 15, 2024]

Calcutta Judge’s Political Turn – An Arranged, Love Marriage?

by Derek O'Brien

“I approached BJP and BJP also approached me”

A sitting Calcutta High Court judge said this on the very same day he tendered his resignation as a judge. Two days later, he joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). This is what you might well call an arranged, love marriage!

That begs serious questions:

  • Should all the rulings made by this judge in the last year, targeting the government of West Bengal, be declared null and void immediately?
  • What happens to the dictum: “Justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done”?
  • How badly does doing preparatory politics from the Bench destroy the impartiality of an institution?

The judge in question could very well put up a (weak) defence, saying this is not the first time this has happened.

A Couple Of ‘Precedents’

In 1967, prior to his retirement, former Chief Justice of India Koka Subba Rao stepped down three months early to run as an Opposition candidate against Congress’s Zakir Hussain in the presidential polls. Similarly, in 1983, former Supreme Court judge Baharul Islam resigned six weeks before his retirement to contest the Lok Sabha polls as a Congress candidate from Assam’s Barpeta seat. More recently, Justice Abhay Thipsay, who gave the verdict against Amit Shah, joined the Congress soon after retirement.

Former Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi now occupies a seat in the Rajya Sabha as a nominated MP. The ‘honourable gentleman’ presided over the Ayodhya and Rafale judgments. A former staff member of the Supreme Court levelled serious allegations against the ‘honourable gentleman’. Sinecure?

After retirement, Justice Abdul Nazeer (the only judge on the Ayodhya bench belonging to the Muslim community) was made governor of Andhra Pradesh. Justice Ashok Bhushan, also on the Ayodhya bench, became chair of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal. Sinecures?

Chief Justice P. Sathasivam retired from the Supreme Court in 2013. He had presided over a Bench that gave significant relief to the then Home Minister of Gujarat, Amit Shah, in the custodial killing case of Tulsiram Prajapati. He was made Governor of Kerala. Sinecure? Or just a coincidence!

On Protecting Judicial Independence

Some members of the Constituent Assembly had strong points of view on the dangers of undermining judicial independence, and proposed measures to protect the same. During the debates, economist and advocate K.T. Shah, member from Bihar, suggested a provision to prevent former Supreme Court and High Court judges from being appointed to executive offices. Shah’s proposal highlighted the potential for abuse if post-retirement positions were not explicitly addressed in the Constitution. He emphasised that the growing availability of executive positions in independent India could exacerbate this issue, warranting a clear and decisive stance to maintain the separation of powers and uphold the integrity of the judiciary.

The actions of the Calcutta High Court judge delivering ‘politically one-sided’ judgments followed by his resignation and immediately donning the jersey of a political party undermines the very foundation of our democracy. This columnist has refrained from even mentioning the name of the retired judge, lest a selfish individual gets more publicity than he warrants.

“Judges should be of stern stuff and tough fibre, unbending before power, economic or political, and they must uphold the core principle of the rule of law which says ‘Be you ever so high, the law is above you’.” These words, spoken by the Supreme Court of India in SP Gupta v Union of India, epitomised the pinnacle of judicial integrity and independence.

In 1995, American academic Dennis Thompson coined the term ‘institutional corruption’ to explain how (parasitic) external influences had compromised the US Congress and made it systematically deviate from its proper purpose.

Closer home, in 2012, a gentleman, whose ideology I did not share, but who personified Parliament 360 degrees, said, “Pre-retirement judgments are influenced by post-retirement jobs”. Wondering what Arun Jaitley would have had to say about all this.

[This article was also published in NDTV | Thursday, March 7, 2024]

The nari shakti jumla: Six times BJP failed women

by Derek O'Brien

The Modi government has launched a few headline-grabbing flagship schemes, ostensibly aimed at improving the lives of women in India. However, the patriarchal mindset that lies at the core of the RSS-BJP belief system has ensured that the outcomes are very different from those envisaged in the scheme documents.

A former RSS chief said that women should be staying at home and cooking. The RSS is the fountainhead of the BJP. Are women allowed in an RSS shakha? So one cannot miss the irony that in the days leading up to Women’s Day (March 8), the Prime Minister, in the face of misogyny under his watch, has been waxing eloquent about “nari shakti”. Here are six instances when his government denigrated women, but they resisted powerfully.

Female farmers

Tens of thousands of women farmers, coming from places as distant as Chhattisgarh, gathered in makeshift camps in Delhi and at the borders of Punjab, Haryana, and UP to protest against the draconian farm bills. Some staged hunger strikes wearing bright yellow scarves that represented mustard fields, while others ran medical camps and soup kitchens. Amidst speeches and silent resistance, when the Supreme Court asked them to go home, the women farmers responded with a loud “No”.

The stakes were high. Distant and exploitative markets had rendered them extremely vulnerable. As per the NCRB, nearly 10 per cent of farmers who committed suicide in 2022 are women. Over 80 per cent of rural women work in agriculture but less than 13 per cent own any land.

The women of Shaheen Bagh

Enraged by the Union government’s decision to impose unconstitutional laws on citizenship against minorities, women protestors retaliated by staging a peaceful demonstration in Delhi’s Shaheen Bagh. The 101-day-long protest caught the world’s imagination as women across religions, ages and walks of life united. Shaheen Bagh became a symbol of intergenerational and intersectional political dissent to protect the Constitution. Inspired by the women there, demonstrations took place across the country.

The government clamped down with violence, specifically targeting minority-dominated areas in BJP-ruled states. In the face of severe backlash that questioned their patriotism, the women of Shaheen Bagh defiantly challenged the Prime Minister to come and speak with them. Of course, he did not.

Champion sportspersons

The sickening story of Brij Bhushan Singh — a BJP Lok Sabha MP and former President of the Wrestling Federation of India — is too well documented to bear repetition. He was present and voting when the Women’s Reservation Bill was being passed in the Lok Sabha. Enough said.

Community healthcare workers

In 2022, 10 lakh female health workers, who tirelessly provided last-mile primary care in India’s villages, were honoured with the WHO Director General’s Global Health Leaders Award. Once the Prime Minister’s tweets ceased, they were promptly cast into obscurity. Despite being the backbone of the nation’s healthcare system, ASHA workers continue to wait for the recognition they deserve.

For the last two years, more than 6,00,000 ASHA workers from all over the country have been protesting against the lack of protective gloves, PPE kits, and masks, delayed payments since the pandemic, absence of insurance coverage, and exploitative working conditions that have pushed them to the brink of poverty.

Chief Minister Ajay Bisht aka Yogi Adityanath had promised to increase the honorarium for ASHAs in Uttar Pradesh, purportedly to end the protests. Turns out, it was another jumla.

Women for Manipur

Since May 2022, over 180 lives have been lost and 60,000 people displaced in Manipur. The much-touted double-engine sarkar has miserably failed to control the situation. In July 2023, horrifying news broke about Manipur. Two women had been stripped naked and were videographed by a mob of men. Women’s organisations from across the country rose in solidarity and organised protest marches and demonstrations in Imphal, Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Delhi, Goa, Bhopal, and Bengaluru. Thousands of women took to the streets demanding the resignation of the Union Home Minister Amit Shah and Manipur Chief Minister Biren Singh, owning moral responsibility for the incident.

It has been nine months, yet neither the state nor the Union government has taken any responsibility. The Prime Minister has not visited the state. In a dangerous precedent, not a single question on the issue has been admitted and answered in Parliament.

MGNREGA workers

Despite being one of the best performers under the scheme, the wages of 59 lakh MGNREGA workers from West Bengal have been withheld. Women constitute more than 50 per cent of the beneficiaries. Their access to livelihood has been cut off.

MGNREGA was more than just an Act; it was a guarantee, a promise by Parliament to the people of India, especially women. Today, that promise lies broken.

[This article was also published in The Indian Express | Friday, March 1, 2024]

Dhruv & Team MPs versus Modi

by Derek O'Brien

Two Dhruvs captured the public imagination this week.

Dhruv Jurel, on Test debut for India, excelled both with the bat and behind the wickets.

Dhruv Jurel (Image courtesy: PTI)

Dhruv Rathee went viral with his new video “Is India becoming a dictatorship?”. Phenomenal 1.5 crore views in a few days, on YouTube alone.

Dhruv Rathee (Image Source: Dhruv Rathee Youtube)

To put this number in perspective, the trailer of Fighter, the new film starring Hrithik Roshan and Deepika Padukone, has 48 million views in a month.

Image courtesy: Viacom18 Studios

Most of what Dhruv Rathee packaged in his video was not new. MPs from Opposition parties have been flagging these issues for a while. Both inside, and outside Parliament. But then who watches Sansad TV! MPs sitting in the Opposition benches have made seven key points in the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha over the past two years or so.

Adv AM Ariff (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Investigative agencies: “You may try to defame it using about nine Central agencies including ED, CBI, NIA, Central Intelligence and even C&AG. We know that you have changed the Enforcement Directorate to election duty by making a mockery of democracy.” – AM Ariff, Communist Party of India (Marxist), 8 August, 2023

Dimple Yadav (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Investigative agencies: “They (BJP) are destroying the institutions right from EC, ED, CBI to others. They are using them as tools to harass the people of the country” – Dimple Yadav, Samajwadi Party, 8 August, 2023

Sougata Roy (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Horse-trading: “BJP has a big washing machine. When Ajit Pawar was in NCP, he was very bad. He has Rs. 70,000 crore irrigation-scam. Now, he has entered BJP’s washing machine. Now, he has become a good man. Amit Shah goes and praises him.” Sougata Roy, All India Trinamool Congress, 8 August, 2023.

Danish Ali Kunwar (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Right to protest: “It is unfortunate that UAPA has been implemented against those carrying out peaceful protests in Delhi and in the country. That is, people have been sent to jail by misusing this law made for those involved in terrorist activities…. It is an attempt to keep innocent people in jail for as long as possible without trial because there is no evidence against them.” (Translated). Danish Ali Kunwar, Ex-Bahujan Samaj Party, 20 September, 2020.

Manish Tewari (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Electoral bonds: “Despite the opposition of the Reserve Bank of India and the Election Commission, the electoral bonds were issued by this government, which has given rise to government corruption… In the general budget of February 2017, this government made a provision that unknown electoral bonds should be issued, for which neither the address of the donor nor the amount of money given is known and there is no information about the person to whom it has been given… Due to this, government corruption has been brought to light.” (Translated). Manish Tewari, Indian National Congress, 21 November, 2019.

Shashi Tharoor (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Federalism: “What we have repeatedly seen under this Government is a brazen effort to curtail the autonomy of States. The PM talks about cooperative federalism, but we are witnessing instead a coercive federalism that seeks to centralise all power in the hands of the Central Government. The problem is it looks as if in the new India, some States will come first if they are ruled by the right party. But others must remain subservient to the political wishes of those in Delhi.” – Shashi Tharoor, Indian National Congress, 3 August, 2023.

Derek O’Brien (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Media: “I am all praise for those independent journalists, the young men and women, who despite all the pressures from the media owners are still going and trying to do their very best for journalism. Today, even the Opposition’s voice is not amplified. Media owners have their agenda. There is an old Zulu proverb. A dog with a bone in its mouth can’t bark. Enough said.” – Derek O’Brien, All India Trinamool Congress, 7 February, 2023.

Kanimozhi Karunanidhi (Image courtesy: Sansad TV)

Role of Governors: “The Governor of Tamil Nadu has delayed assent to around 20 Bills passed by the Tamil Nadu Legislature. It is not that just Tamil Nadu stands alone in this fight. You have seen what happened in West Bengal and Maharashtra. In Kerala, the Governor threatens to withdraw Ministers. It is the same situation in Nagaland and Telangana. I think we have to fight battles with the Governor of every State where the Government is a non-BJP Government.” – Kanimozhi Karunanidhi, Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, 7 February, 2023.

P.S. Your columnist has been in politics for over 20 years now. But I have never been trolled as badly as when I shared the Dhruv Rathee video on social media.

Let Young MPs Light Up Parliament Which Has Become a “Deep, Dark Chamber”

by Derek O'Brien

Very happy with the news that Swati Maliwal, the young firebrand chief of the Delhi Commission for Women (DCW), has been nominated by the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) as a candidate for election to Rajya Sabha. Maliwal (39), when elected, will be part of a small group of young MPs in Rajya Sabha who are in their 30s and early 40s.

This includes Jebi Mather from the Congress, AAP’s Raghav Chadha (35), and three of my colleagues from the Trinamool Congress.

One is Saket Gokhale (36), among India’s foremost RTI activists, who has also faced incarceration for his activism. There’s Prakash Chik Baraik (42) a popular and rising tribal leader from the Alipurduars who comes from a humble background of tea estate workers. More young blood. Meet Samirul Islam (36) an alumnus of IIT Delhi who spent a short while overseas and then gave it all up to come back to India and work at the grassroots for the welfare of the socially challenged, especially migrant workers.

Then there’s the plucky Jebi Mather of the Congress from Kerala who is an advocate, a former Municipal Councillor and, astonishingly, the first woman Rajya Sabha MP from Kerala in the last 42 years.

These young colleagues of mine have entered Rajya Sabha with a great amount of hope and with the determination to excel in their responsibilities as parliamentarians. Whenever I chat with them, I am glad to see their enthusiasm and their faith in parliamentary procedure.

Let these young people do all it takes to light up an institution that is being turned into a deep, dark chamber.

No place for disagreements

In 1987, the Chairman of Rajya Sabha emphasised, “Every member is entitled to express his opinion. Merely because you disagree, you cannot shut him down. Then, there will be no parliament.”

Between 2019-2023, MPs faced suspension on multiple occasions, marking a 13-fold increase from the 15th Lok Sabha (2009-2014). Compare that to MPs from the ruling dispensation. Despite allegations of sexual harassment, use of toxic communal slurs on the floor of the House, and enabling a security breach in parliament, no action has been taken against any of them. No BJP MP has faced suspension in the last 10 years.

Quality of Committees

Parliamentary committees play a vital role by taking up crucial policy matters for discussion, inviting participation from stakeholders and domain experts. Consider this. The Home Affairs Committee while analysing the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) Bill, 2006, which had 41 amendments, sat for 11 sittings. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023, one of the three Bills overhauling the entire criminal justice system, with 356 amendments (almost nine times that of the CrPC Bill) was discussed in just 13 sittings.

Bulldozing Legislation

Former leader of Rajya Sabha, N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar, stressed in the Constituent Assembly that the purpose of a second chamber is to conduct dignified debates, delaying impulsive and hasty legislation. Significant Bills like the 1977 Banking Service Commission Repeal Bill and the 2002 Prevention of Terrorism Bill were passed in Lok Sabha but rejected by Rajya Sabha.

In the last winter session, 47% of Opposition MPs were suspended for demanding a discussion and statement from the Home Minister on the parliament security breach. As a result, the discussion on the Provisional Collection of Taxes Bill saw participation by just six members and was passed in 30 minutes. The Telecommunications Bill saw only eight members taking part in the discussion and was passed in an hour. The three critical Criminal Law Bills were passed in five hours, with the Home Minister himself speaking for an hour. Since 2019, over 100 Bills have been passed in less than two hours.

Stealth and Secrecy

Rule 69 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Council of States (Rajya Sabha) states that a Bill should be circulated to MPs two days before it is taken up for consideration. Though the Chairman has discretionary power, this was a long established practice that had become convention.

Today, secrecy reigns supreme. Take the case of the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Bill, 2019, which stripped J&K of its statehood. The Supplementary List of Business reached the members at 11:18 am, while the Bill was introduced at 11:07 am. It was discussed and passed on the very same day.

Not House of Elders, but Council of States

The Council of States, unlike the House of Lords in the UK, was designed to genuinely deliberate and represent states and their interests. A notable instance of this occurred in 1989 when Rajya Sabha rejected the Nagarpalika Bill passed by the Rajiv Gandhi government. The Opposition in Rajya Sabha perceived it as a threat to the federal structure of the country.

Post 2014, there has been a paradigm shift. The Opposition has been systematically targeted, from muting microphones and blacking out live feed, to outright suspension. The principles of federalism have been trampled upon. Bills aimed at weakening state governments such as the J&K Reorganisation Bill, 2023 and the Government of NCT of Delhi (Amendment) Bill, 2023 were passed in less than half a day.

In March 2016, the Prime Minister had stated in the Rajya Sabha, “This is the Upper House. Whatever happens in this House, its impact is felt on Lok Sabha, Assemblies and Municipal Corporations. So we should think how to create an atmosphere by which democracy can be strengthened.”

[This article was also published in NDTV | Friday, January 12, 2024]

An A to Z List For 2023

by Derek O'Brien

A random A to Z List for 2023. You too can draw up your personal A to Z List for the year that just slipped by.

A: Artificial Intelligence. ChatGPT has still not become this columnist’s personal AI assistant. Have you used DALL.E yet to create artwork from just a descriptive sentence? Deep fakes are a nightmare. For better or for worse, AI is here to stay.

B: Barbie. The only English film this columnist watched this year. Loved it. Innocuous at first glance but the underlying theme of women empowerment endures.

C: Chandrayaan-3. Our scientists at ISRO. Our world champions.

D: Demographic dividend. India surpassed China to become the most populous country in the world. Our demographic dividend is expected to peak around 2041. The next eight years are crucial.

E: Election Commission. The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Bill, 2023 passed in the recently concluded winter session of parliament effectively gives the Union government unilateral power to appoint the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners. Neutrality?

F: Fascism. Noun. A way of organising a society in which a government ruled by a dictator controls the lives of the people and in which people are not allowed to disagree with the government.

G: G20 summit. A rotational presidency of G20 packaged as a gargantuan achievement.

H: Hangzhou Asian Games. Record 107 medals for India, 28 gold, 38 silver, 41 bronze.

I: Inflation. Compared to 2014, the price of rice has gone up by 56 per cent, wheat by 59 per cent, milk by 61 per cent, tomatoes by 115 per cent, and toor dal by 120 per cent. The price of an LPG cylinder crossed ₹ 1,000.

J: Jumla…

K: King Khan. What a year! Pathaan. Jawaan. Dunki. Someone’s come a long way from his appearance in the TV serial Fauji in 1988.

L: LGBTQ. Even though the Supreme Court declined to legalise same-sex marriage, thousands took part in South Asia’s oldest pride walk. Where else, but Kolkata! ❤️ you all.

M: Manipur. 180 days. 175 dead. Over 70,000 displaced. HE will still not visit.

N: Naatu Naatu. Unpopular opinion. Not the greatest song to come out of India. However, thrilled it was awarded the best original song at the 95th Academy Awards. The first Indian song to achieve this.

O: Odisha train accident. 296 people died in the crash, the deadliest in over two decades. A CAG report revealed that over 50 per cent of the compulsory track safety inspections were not done. Railway safety has to mean more than megalomaniacal selfie points at stations.

P: Parliament. 2001 attack: the Home Minister LK Advani and Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee gave a statement in the house within three working days. A full discussion happened on the floor of parliament over two days. 2023: 146 MPs suspended for demanding a discussion and statement from the Home Minister. Radio silence from the government on the floor of parliament.

Q: Quiz. There used to be the Bournvita Quiz Contest, Quiz Time and more. Nowadays, you very often see the word ‘quiz’ in the headlines. Guess why? Move over Siddhartha Basu, Amitabh Bachchan and another quizmaster. ED and CBI ‘quiz’ political opponents of this government every day.

R: Rocky aur Rani ki Prem Kahani. Fun film. Accuse this columnist of parliamentary bias, but the standout performance was that of Jaya Bachchan in the role of Dhanalaxmi Randhawa.

S: Sexual harassment against wrestlers. Champions in tears. Returning their medals. Quitting the sport. Heartbreak. (Someone has come up with the spunky idea that there should be one candidate put up to fight the good fight against the sitting Prime Minister in the Varanasi Lok Sabha seat. Sakshi Malik)

T: Turkey earthquake. Lethal. 7.8 magnitude earthquake resulted in 50,000 lives lost. In a show of global solidarity, citizens from 94 countries joined in the relief and rescue efforts.

U: Uttarakhand tunnel collapse. 41 workers trapped for 17 days before they were rescued with the help of 12 rat-hole miners. Real life heroes: Feroz Qureshi, Munna Quereshi, Rashid, Irshad, Naseem, Monu, Naseer, Ankur, Jatin, Saurabh, Waqeel Hasan, and Devender. (Ironic, since rat-hole mining has been banned in India since 2014).

V: Vacancies. There are 6,000 seats vacant in central universities for SC/ST/OBC students. 5,000 posts of judges vacant in district and subordinate courts. Over 82,000 vacancies in paramilitary forces. 1.5 lakh posts vacant in railways.

W: World Cup. India broke a billion hearts. Shami sprinted to the fastest 50 wickets in World Cup Cricket.

X: No, Elon.

Y: Youth. One in four youth in India is unemployed. 45 per cent of young graduates under the age of 25 do not have jobs.

Z: Zionism. Go google the term.

[This article was also published in NDTV | Tuesday, December 30, 2023]

In Parliament, NDA May Well Be ‘No Data Available’

by Derek O'Brien

Parliamentary questions rarely make the headlines. However, questions raised and answered in parliament are a treasure trove of information. In the last decade, Question Hour has been a good opportunity for members in the opposition to expose the shallowness of this government and its disdain for solid data. From the hundreds of questions asked by Members of Parliament to this government during the ‘strangulated’ winter session of parliament, this columnist has chosen just seven questions to make the point that the NDA (National Democratic Alliance) could very well stand for No Data Available (NDA).

1. Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment (Manual Scavenging)

Lok Sabha’s Aparupa Poddar’s (Trinamool Congress) and Rajya Sabha’s Md. Nadimul Haque (Trinamool) asked questions regarding data on manhole cleaning robots and deaths due to cleaning septic tanks. Conveniently, the government claimed the absence of centralised maintenance for this information. This is despite the Finance Minister’s explicit mention of putting an end to manual scavenging in the Union Budget 2023. If only words could provide relief to communities in India that have experienced the highest indignities of caste for over a millennium.

2. Ministry of Corporate Affairs (Chinese Companies in India)

The response to Shyam Yadav Singh’s (BSP) question on Chinese companies operating in India in the space of providing loans through apps was bewildering. The answer revealed that 53 Chinese companies have established a place of business in India. But the government has ‘no data available’ on the details of their business activities.

3. Ministry of Education (Displacement of Tribal Students in Manipur)

In response to Lorho S Pfoze’s (NPF) inquiry in Lok Sabha, on tribal students displaced in the Manipur ethnic violence, the Ministry of Education sidestepped the crucial issue of rehabilitation. Even after seven months of Manipur unrest, there is an absence of any concrete government effort to collect data on the students affected by the ethnic conflict, clearly demonstrating a disregard for their welfare. The Prime Minister in 2016 was lauded for his statement, “It is my conviction to bring the North-East at par with other developed regions of the country.” These words seem hollow when the students, perhaps the most affected by the ethnic strife, are the least of the government’s priorities. The ministry responded with a plan for online education for students missing out on crucial years of their development. Internet shutdowns, gentlemen.

4. Ministry of Finance (Loan Recovery)

S Venkatesan (CPI-M)) asked a pointed question on the quantum of loans written off and the corresponding debt recovery from bad loans spanning the financial years 2014-15 to 2022-23. In response, the ministry said that public sector banks have written off a colossal amount of ₹ 10.4 lakh crore in loans while only managing to recover a mere ₹ 1.6 lakh crore from these written-off loans. This substantial loss of public funds demands scrutiny and fuels concerns about serious setbacks to the exchequer.

5. Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions (Pending RTI Appeals)

AD Singh (RJD) asked a question in Rajya Sabha on appeals under the Right to Information Act pending with the Central Information Commission and State Information Commission. The ministry robotically replied that the pendency has drastically reduced and the disposal rate increased. Ironically, no information was provided to substantiate these claims. No such attempt was even made to provide an answer about the states, and a dry “this information is with the state governments” was received in response.

6. Ministry of Railways (Kavach System in Indian Railways)

Despite 2023 having been a torrid year for the Indian Railways, with devastating accidents like the ones in Balasore, Buxar and Vishakhapatnam, questions about the Kavach safety system in trains were met with an unsatisfactory response. The pertinent question was asked by Dhiraj Prasad Sahu (Congress), KRN Rajeshkumar (DMK), Digvijaya Singh (Congress) and Dr. Amee Yajnik (Congress) in Rajya Sabha. The answer revealed that the system has only been deployed in the South Central Railway zone. The government didn’t think it necessary to provide any insight, plan, or justification as to why the other zones are left without adequate safety mechanisms.

7. Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution (Cancellation of Ration Cards)

Lok Sabha MP Deepak Adhikari (Trinamool Congress) asked a question about the deletion and cancellation of fake ration cards over the past two years. The data provided revealed that Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh together accounted for a whopping 27 lakh cards, whereas West Bengal only had 6 lakh cards cancelled. One is forced to think- why were so many fake cards required in the first place?

Postscript: For over 60 years, Question Hour was taken up at 11 am, followed by Zero Hour at 12 noon in Rajya Sabha. Question Hour would often be disrupted due to MPs wanting to raise crucial issues at the start of the day. In 2014, former Chairman Hamid Ansari flipped the timings and now Zero Hour starts at 11 am, followed by Question Hour at 12 noon. A noteworthy reform by a presiding officer. (Reform and presiding officers. Let’s not say a word more!)

[This article was also published in NDTV | Saturday, December 27, 2023]